The Nice Guys (2016): A Noir Comedy That Found Its Real Audience After Leaving Theaters
Midway through The Nice Guys, Holland March hides in a bathroom stall during a shootout, more worried about getting shot than about helping anyone else. It's the move Shane Black built his career on: real danger played for a laugh without pretending it isn't real, and it's why a flop from 2016 still finds fans a decade later.
Heads up: TopMovieList may earn a small commission if you buy or rent through an Amazon link in this post, at no added cost to you.
It's not quite a detective mystery, a slapstick comedy, or a gritty noir throwback. It's all three at once, powered by Ryan Gosling and Russell Crowe, who generate more chemistry here than either has managed elsewhere.
What The Nice Guys Is About
The film is set in 1977 Los Angeles, treated like a character: smog over the hills, porn theaters lit up a block from family diners, shot with a grain and faded palette pulled off an old photo lab receipt.
Holland March (Ryan Gosling)
March is a widowed single father working as a private investigator, bad at it in ways that are funny rather than sad: hurt constantly by his own carelessness (he once falls out a window onto broken glass), drinking too much, squeamish about violence up close. He genuinely wants to do right by his clients.
Jackson Healy (Russell Crowe)
Healy is muscle for hire, paid to rough up whoever is bothering someone; the first time we see March, Healy is breaking his arm for a job. The two work the case from opposite directions, team up out of necessity, and Healy has more conscience than his job suggests.
Their case starts small, a missing girl named Amelia, and widens into a murdered adult-film actress, a Department of Justice official played by Kim Basinger, and a Detroit automaker burying pollution-control tech to protect profits. None of that sounds like comedy on paper, but on screen it's the backbone keeping the jokes aloft.
The Comedy Still Lands Because the Plot Never Stops for It
Black made his name on buddy-driven action comedies like Lethal Weapon and Kiss Kiss Bang Bang, and The Nice Guys is the fullest version of that instinct yet.
Gosling plays it physical
March spends the movie getting his hand slammed in car doors, choking on a drink at the worst moment, and treating every dangerous situation like a personal betrayal. It's broad physical comedy, and Gosling commits fully instead of winking at the camera.
Crowe plays the straight man
Healy barely raises his voice through the film, and that's why it works. He absorbs March's chaos with the patience of a man who's genuinely seen worse, and his stillness turns March's panic funny instead of grating.
Their chemistry runs on friction, not warmth
They argue about money, method, and who's in charge, yet keep ending up on the same side. Watching two men who don't especially like each other slowly become a functioning team, with no scene where they say so out loud, beats any speech about friendship.
The mystery never stops to make room for the jokes
A lot of comedies pause the story for a bit. Here, jokes happen because two mismatched men are trying to solve an actual case and keep getting in each other's way, so nothing feels bolted on.
The 1977 Los Angeles Look Does a Lot of the Work
The Nice Guys is dressed in browns, tans, and neon signage reflected off wet asphalt, period detail that could tip into costume-party kitsch and never does. Cars, wallpaper, even the film stock's grain sell the era without anyone commenting on how "seventies" it all looks.
The Mystery Underneath the Jokes Actually Holds Up
Strip out the comedy and there's a real noir plot underneath: a missing-person case that widens into murder, a corporate cover-up, and a government official with her own reasons to keep it buried. The catalytic-converter angle, an automaker hiding pollution-control tech to dodge a profit hit, gives the conspiracy a mundane motive rather than a cartoonish one, with clues planted early enough to reward a second viewing.
Holly March Is the Film's Moral Center
Angourie Rice plays Holly, Holland's teenage daughter and the one character who consistently makes better decisions than the adults around her. She invites herself along on the investigation, calls her father out when he's lying to himself, and out-detects both March and Healy more than once. Her dry wit and her relationship with both men give the film real stakes beyond the next punchline.
Why The Nice Guys Deserved Better at the Box Office
On a reported $50 million budget, The Nice Guys made only about $36 million domestically, a rough outcome for two stars and strong reviews. Marketing never settled on what it was selling: comedy, noir throwback, or action picture; the release date sat next to bigger studio tentpoles; and "1970s buddy mystery with no franchise attached" is a hard sell regardless.
Streaming and home video did what theaters couldn't. Once people could stream The Nice Guys on Amazon instead of buying a ticket, The Nice Guys kept finding viewers who'd missed it, and word of mouth turned it into a movie people push on friends instead of one they half remember.
The Sequel Talk
Shane Black has said more than once he'd like to make a follow-up, and fan affection for March and Healy hasn't cooled. Nothing has been officially greenlit.
A Few Things Worth Knowing
The screenplay, credited to Shane Black and Anthony Bagarozzi, kicked around Hollywood for years before this cast and director made it. It sits next to Lethal Weapon and Kiss Kiss Bang Bang in Black's filmography: a real mystery wearing an action movie's clothes, dialogue that lands because the characters never notice how funny they are, and a soundtrack of period-accurate needle drops that sells 1977 too.
For more on the cast and background, see the The Nice Guys movie page.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is The Nice Guys based on a book?
No. It's an original screenplay by Shane Black and Anthony Bagarozzi, not adapted from anything.
Is this similar to Kiss Kiss Bang Bang?
Yes, deliberately. Both pair a reluctant partnership with a plot more tangled than it looks, and both treat violence as embarrassing and messy rather than heroic. If you want to see where Black first worked out that tone, Kiss Kiss Bang Bang is on Amazon too.
Is a sequel actually happening?
Not yet. Shane Black would like to make one, but no studio has put it into production.
Final Take
The Nice Guys is proof a movie can lose money in theaters and still win in the long run. It came and went in weeks in 2016, then spent a decade building the kind of following studios spend marketing budgets trying to manufacture. If you haven't seen the bathroom-stall shootout yet, it's worth the trip, and you can watch The Nice Guys on Amazon whenever you're ready.
About the Author
Hoon Choi is a software engineer and movie buff who built TopMovieList.com to help film lovers explore the best in cinema. With a passion for storytelling, UI/UX design, and SEO-driven content, Hoon blends technical expertise with a love for pop culture. When he’s not coding or watching films, he’s probably digging into astrology, exploring Korea, or brainstorming his next side project.
