Superman Through the Ages: Why We’re Hyped for the 2025 Reboot

Superman Through the Ages: From Reeve to Gunn's 2025 Reboot

Faster Than a Speeding Bullet...

James Gunn's Superman opened on July 11, 2025, took the number one spot at the box office that weekend, and closed out its debut at $125 million domestic once Monday's actuals came in above the initial $122 million Sunday estimate. That's the best opening ever for a solo Superman film, ahead of Man of Steel's $116 million bow in 2013, though Batman v Superman's ensemble debut cleared $166 million in 2016 and still holds the bigger record for the character overall. The reviews backed up the number: critics settled the film in the low to mid 80s on Rotten Tomatoes, audiences pushed their score into the 90s, and it walked away with an A minus CinemaScore from opening night crowds, the kind of reception that turns a strong debut into an actual hit rather than a front loaded weekend that fades by the second Friday. A year later, it's a good moment to trace how Christopher Reeve's cape became Henry Cavill's armor became David Corenswet's suit, and why James Gunn's version landed the way it did.

A quick note before we get into it: some of the links below are Amazon affiliate links, and TopMovieList may earn a small commission on qualifying purchases made through them, at no extra cost to you.

The Original Hero: Christopher Reeve's Legacy

Superman: The Movie (1978) is the reason every other film on this list exists. Richard Donner shoots it like a myth: a slow first act on Krypton and in Smallville before Christopher Reeve ever puts on the suit, John Williams' score doing half the emotional work, and a genuine belief that a man could fly sold entirely through Reeve's face rather than the effects. If you've never actually sat down with it, the original is easy to find on Amazon and holds up far better than you'd expect from a film pushing fifty.

Superman II (1980) came closest to matching it. Terence Stamp's General Zod turning "kneel before Zod" into a real threat, and Reeve giving up his powers for love only to have to win them back, still plays as one of the better superhero sequels made, even with the behind the scenes mess of Donner getting replaced partway through by Richard Lester, who finished the film and took sole directing credit. It's worth tracking down if you haven't seen it; Superman II is available on Amazon for anyone who wants to watch Stamp chew the scenery firsthand.

Then it got rough. Superman III (1983) pairs Reeve with Richard Pryor and splits its tone between broad comedy and a genuinely strange subplot where synthetic kryptonite corrupts Superman into a leering, unshaven double who has to fight his own good half to a standstill in a junkyard. Superman IV: The Quest for Peace (1987) is worse for reasons that had nothing to do with the script: producer Cannon Films was collapsing financially and slashed the budget from a planned $36 million down to roughly $17 million right before shooting started. The nuclear disarmament plot was ambitious; the visible seams in every flying shot are the real story.

The 2000s Revival: Superman Returns (2006)

Bryan Singer treated the Donner films as scripture rather than history to move past, casting Brandon Routh as a Clark Kent who looks and sounds close enough to Reeve that the resemblance became the film's whole selling point. It's a handsome, mournful movie about Superman returning from a long absence to find Lois Lane engaged and raising a son who might be his, and what it isn't is fun. Reported production costs range from roughly $204 million to the $270 million figure Box Office Mojo lists, with Warner Bros. never settling on one official number publicly and tax rebates muddying the math either way. A worldwide gross around $391 million against costs in that range reads as a disappointment rather than a hit, and the gap was wide enough to kill the planned sequel and send the franchise back to the drawing board.

The Snyder Era: A Darker Man of Steel

Man of Steel (2013), directed by Zack Snyder and starring Henry Cavill, threw out the Donner playbook: a Krypton redesigned from scratch, a Clark Kent who spends the back half leveling most of Metropolis fighting Zod, and a finale where he snaps his enemy's neck rather than find another way. It split fans, but it grossed roughly $668 million worldwide, and Cavill sold the internal conflict even when the script didn't earn it.

Batman v Superman (2016) doubled down on that darkness and paid for it. Critics and fans zeroed in on specifics: a Batman who brands criminals and guns down henchmen, a climax where the fight stops because both men's mothers happen to share the name Martha, and a theatrical cut that felt visibly chopped down. That's a fair read of half the story. What gets left out is that Justice League (2017/2021) is really two separate films released four years apart: the theatrical cut that hit cinemas in 2017, and the Snyder Cut that fans spent years campaigning for. Snyder left the sequel during post production after a family tragedy, and the theatrical cut that Joss Whedon reshaped in his place was widely panned. Zack Snyder's Justice League finally arrived on HBO Max in 2021 at more than double the runtime, funded by that same fan campaign, and landed far better with the people who'd been asking for it. It's an easier watch than its four hour runtime suggests, and the Snyder Cut is streaming on Amazon for anyone curious what the fuss was about. Through all of it, Cavill's Superman kept a fan base the films around him didn't always deserve.

The 2025 Reboot: Skipping the Origin Story

Gunn didn't retell the origin story a fifth time. His Superman opens three years into David Corenswet's career as the hero, already partnered with Rachel Brosnahan's Lois Lane, already dealing with a superdog named Krypto and a fictional war between the nations of Boravia and Jarhanpur. Skipping Krypton and Kansas for the fifth time was the right call; it let the film spend its runtime on a hero already weighing his instincts against the messier politics of intervening in someone else's conflict. A year on from its theatrical run, Superman is available on Amazon if you missed it the first time around, or want an excuse for a rewatch.

Gunn was also unusually direct about his intent. In an interview with The Times of London just before release, he called the character "the story of an immigrant" and said the film was ultimately about basic human kindness, a comment that set off an immediate backlash online from people who hadn't seen it yet. In a separate conversation with Rolling Stone, he drew a sharper distinction: "Hope is something outside of ourselves... It's about being loving, being kind, and how that compassion is really the answer to everything." That distinction plays out on screen in how relentlessly decent Corenswet's performance is, choosing kindness in small, undramatic moments rather than waiting for a cosmic reason to be good.

Superman vs. the Antihero Decade

We're well into an entertainment landscape where the antihero is the default setting. The Boys spent multiple seasons turning "what if superheroes were actually monsters" into prestige television, and Joker won an Oscar for asking audiences to sympathize with a man radicalized into violence. Gunn's Superman is a direct rebuttal to that mode, not by accident but by his own stated design: a hero who is simply, uncynically good, in a moment when online culture rewards the opposite instinct. Whether that reads as refreshing or corny depends on how exhausted you personally are by prestige nihilism, but it's a real swing, and that's more than most franchise entries attempt.

Final Thoughts

From Quest for Peace's gutted budget to Superman Returns' quiet disappointment at the box office to whatever this new one turns out to be a decade from now, Superman has survived some spectacularly bad stewardship and keeps coming out the other side still meaning something. What I'm most interested in isn't whether Gunn nailed the tone: plenty of people have already argued that both ways. It's whether a Krypto subplot and a fictional border war can carry a franchise the way "truth, justice, and the American way" used to, without leaning on another trip back to Krypton to remind us who this guy is.