Rabbit Hole (2010): Grief, Healing, and Nicole Kidman’s Most Underrated Role

Teenager Jason Willette draws comic books about parallel universes: versions of the world where nothing goes wrong, where the family dog doesn't get loose, where the car never turns onto that street. He's the one who was driving the car that killed Becca and Howie's young son, and before Rabbit Hole (2010) is over, he shows Becca one of them. That's the image the film keeps returning to, and it says more about what kind of grief movie this is than any plot summary could.

TopMovieList may earn a commission on qualifying Amazon purchases made through the links in this piece, at no extra cost to you.

John Cameron Mitchell directed it, adapting David Lindsay-Abaire's Pulitzer-winning play, and he treats grief as something that happens in ordinary rooms instead of big dramatic ones. Nobody collapses screaming on the floor here. Instead there's a marriage quietly coming apart, and trying, just as quietly, not to.

The Dog Got Out

Becca (Nicole Kidman) and Howie (Aaron Eckhart) are still living in the house they bought when their son was born. He's the reason it's so quiet now. He ran into the street after the family dog, and a teenager's car caught him. That's the whole tragedy, told in one sentence, and the film spends the rest of its runtime showing how two people survive a sentence like that.

Howie rewatches old phone videos of their son and keeps going to the support group. Becca gave the dog away, cleared out the closet, and stopped going to the group weeks ago. Neither one accuses the other of grieving wrong, but you can feel them thinking it. Then Becca starts following Jason, first from a distance, then not, and Rabbit Hole turns from a movie about loss into a movie about what she's actually looking for when she finds him.

Kidman, Eckhart, and Wiest Grieve Three Different Ways

Kidman built her whole performance out of not performing. Becca barely raises her voice. She goes quiet and exact instead, answering people in short sentences that let you feel how much it's costing her not to say what she actually thinks. It's a performance made of withholding rather than release, and it earned her an Academy Award nomination for Best Actress: proof the Academy will occasionally reward stillness over a big emotional set piece.

Eckhart plays Howie as a man who's decided that if he keeps enough routines running, the house won't notice anything is missing. And Dianne Wiest, as Becca's mother, has already buried a child of her own, years earlier, in circumstances very different from an accident. Wiest gets one of the film's best passages about grief changing shape rather than ending, and she delivers it like someone who's said it to herself a hundred times before she ever said it out loud. Watching the three of them share a kitchen is like watching three separate coping strategies fail to sync up.

"God Needed Another Angel"

Rabbit Hole has one scene that explains its whole approach to grief, and it happens in a church basement. Becca is at the support group Howie still attends, listening to another bereaved parent explain that her son is in a better place because God needed another angel. Becca doesn't cry. She gets angry, and specific: if God is all-powerful, why didn't He just make a new angel instead of taking somebody's kid? Why does He need to recruit? It's a small, human moment that stings, unfair to a woman who was only trying to help, and it's the opposite of what a lesser script would have written there. That's the film's whole method in one scene: it trusts that real grief looks less like sobbing and more like sniping at strangers over bad theology, and it never once reaches for a swelling score to tell you how to feel about it.

A Director Known for Excess, Working in Whispers

Mitchell made his name with Hedwig and the Angry Inch, glam and proudly theatrical, and before that with Shortbus, which is about as unrestrained as an American drama gets. None of that instinct shows up here. Rabbit Hole is shot in flat daylight and muted color, in a house and a neighborhood that look like a hundred other houses and neighborhoods, because Becca and Howie's tragedy didn't happen somewhere special. It happened at an address like anyone's. Mitchell keeps the camera at a polite distance, mostly still, and he lets scenes end a beat before you expect them to, on a half-finished sentence or a closing door. That's the mechanism this kind of understated drama runs on, restraint standing in for spectacle, and it's the same distinction our Movie Genre Analysis Guide draws when it separates a real character piece from a movie that's only dressed like one. The movie starts to feel like it's grieving too, cutting itself off before it says too much.

Buried Between The King's Speech and Black Swan

Rabbit Hole came out the same fall as The King's Speech and Black Swan, two much louder films that dominated that awards season. A quiet two-hander about a couple grieving a dead child was never going to out-shout a movie with a swan transformation or a stuttering king, not when The King's Speech alone picked up twelve Oscar nominations to Rabbit Hole's one. It got its due in narrower ways instead: the Kidman nomination, strong reviews, and a slow-build reputation among people who stumble onto it later on streaming and can't quite shake it. It's the kind of film that undersells itself in a trailer and then overperforms in someone's memory five years on. If quiet grief over spectacle sounds like your speed, you can watch Rabbit Hole on Amazon and judge for yourself why it stuck around.

The Play, the Comic Book, and a First-Time Actor Named Miles Teller

David Lindsay-Abaire wrote the original stage play and adapted it himself for the screen, and Nicole Kidman produced the film through her company, Blossom Films, which optioned Lindsay-Abaire's play and shepherded it to the screen. The "rabbit hole" of the title comes straight from Jason's comic: his sketched-out theory of parallel universes, where every choice branches into another version of events, including the version where the accident never happens. It's exactly the kind of idea a guilty teenager would cling to, and the film is smart enough to let it stay a little silly and a little profound at the same time.

Jason is played by Miles Teller, in his first film role. It's strange to watch now, knowing what he became, but at the time he was an unknown actor holding his own opposite Kidman, playing a kid who has to carry an unbearable kind of guilt without turning into a symbol instead of a person.

Two Questions People Actually Ask

Step out of essay mode for a second, because these are the two things people actually type into a search bar after the credits roll.

Is it based on a true story?

No. It's adapted from David Lindsay-Abaire's play, which is fiction, not a real family's account. It just doesn't feel like fiction, because grief this specific is hard to invent from nothing.

Did Nicole Kidman win the Oscar for it?

No. She lost Best Actress that year to Natalie Portman, who won for Black Swan.

The Porch, at the End

Rabbit Hole doesn't end with a resolution, because there isn't one available to Becca and Howie. It ends with the two of them sitting outside at a small gathering, not talking about anything important, and Howie reaches over and takes her hand. That's it. No music swells, nobody says the thing that fixes it. But it's the first time in the whole film the two of them touch like people who are still married to each other, instead of people who happen to share a house and a dead son.

That's what earns this film a spot on a list like this one. It doesn't promise Becca and Howie get better. It just shows them choosing, again, to sit next to each other, which might be the most honest ending a movie about this subject could give you. If that ending is calling to you, stream it on Amazon and give it the ninety-some quiet minutes it asks for.